Well, people never know what they want. It's true , we want something fresh, but don't over do it.

If you hand pick 20 maps and then add 3 maps to those 20 and rotate every month those 3 extra, it would work. People Will then focus on those 20, and might care for those 3 maps of the month. You could tag them with "FEBMAP16.Mapname". I'm sure everyone will be curious for those 3 maps, as they will be handpicked. And many things can happen, some could end up being fan favorites, since there won't be too many maps to consider. And might inspire some to do a map, since it will get attention, and not just "another one".

Less is more.